Showing posts with label bundle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bundle. Show all posts

Sunday, June 23, 2013

The Problem Creation Problem: A Game of Thrones.

In "A Storm of Swords" (one of the fantasy novels that serve as a literary foundation for the popular HBO TV Show A Game of Thrones) the author creates a lot of problems for his characters to solve and for readers to enjoy. The more intractable the problem, the more entertainment value it provides because it requires ingenious solutions and plenty of opportunities for dangerous mistakes.
Personal intrigues about love, lust, and power aside, the novel poses interesting technical problems as well. For example, we find Jon Snow and less than a hundred of his fellow guards in charge of defending The Wall against more than a hundred thousand of Wildlings. The Wall itself is impregnable to the low tech assailants, but it has a narrow passage that allows people to get beyond the Wall. Jon Snow's biggest challenge is to prevent the Wildlings from getting through the passage.



In the book, both sides show great creativity in attacking and defending the passage. There's a king of giants who rips out its iron gate; there's a brave dozen of guards who kill him in the process, etc. The fight goes on for pages and its a lot of fun to read.

But when I put my inventor hat on, I wonder why have the passage at all. On the internal side of the Wall, the guards use an equivalent of a large elevator to get on and off the Wall. Since the guards on the Wall are in full control of the elevator, no enemy can get over the Wall. In short, the elevator is the safest method to get people "through" the Wall. You would think that the builders of the Wall should be smart enough to use the elevator on both sides; especially, on the dangerous side because the Wildlings would have no chance to penetrate the Wall when the guards lift or temporarily disable the elevator. Furthermore, according to the book, the passage is so narrow that its throughput capacity is no greater than that of the elevator. Then, why do we have the passage at all if it introduces a major design flaw?

Well, from a fun creation perspective, the passage is a "planted" intractable problem that allows the author to keep the struggle for the Wall going for pages and pages and pages. Not having the passage would be a great technology solution, but its entertainment value would be almost non-existent. As we discuss in the Prologue of Scalable Innovation, we humans prefer the entertainment value. That's why our discussions and practices of creativity are skewed toward fun and games, including games of thrones.

--
my earlier post on the Problem Creation Problem.

tags: problem, solution, entertainment, separation, bundle





Friday, June 12, 2009

Problem creation problem: Apollo vs Cassandra.

Ancient gods are particularly good at creating problems for others. Apollo, one of the most powerful Greek gods, fell in love with Cassandra, the daughter of Trojan king Priam. Apollo seduced the girl by promising that he would teach her the art of prophecy. Having learnt the art, Cassandra rejected him. Angry Appollo, unable to take back her knowledge, decided to put a curse on it, by declaring that Cassandra's prophecies will never be accepted or believed.

As a result, Cassandra's last tragic prophecy that Troy will be destroyed by the Greeks fell on deaf ears of her compatriots. According to the legend, during the sack of the city, which she so perfectly predicted, Cassandra, the daughter of a Trojan king, was captured, raped, and then killed by an ordinary Greek soldier.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Problem creation problem

There seems to exist a whole class of problems, in which solution involves creation of an unsolvable problem for one's opponent. As an example, here's how in the 9th century two enterprising Venetian merchants fooled Alexandria port officials and smuggled Saint Mark's body out of Egypt:

...two Venetian merchants returned from Egypt with a corpse which they claimed to be that of the Evangelist (St Mark), stolen from his Alexandrian tomb.
...[as the body was sitting on a Venetian ship in Alexandria's harbor] the odour of sanctity that issued from the body was becoming so strong that, in the words of one chronicler, 'If all the spices of the world had been gathered together in Alexandria, they could not have so perfumed the city.' Suspicions were understandably aroused, and local officials arrived to search the ship; but the Venetians had covered their prize with quantities of pork, at the first sight of which the officials, pious Muslims to a man, cried 'Kanzir, kanzir!' - 'Pig, pig!' - and fled in horror. -- A History of Venice, by John Julius Norwich. ISBN 0-679-72197-5. p.29.

As we can see, the solution to the smugglers' problem was to make it impossible for the port officials to inspect the ship. Using our "inventorese" language, we can say that the merchants achieved their goal by preventing their opponents from solving a detection problem.
Given that the vast majority of such problems are solved by applying the Separation Principles, problem creation problems must have a solution based on certain anti-Separation Principles. In other words, to create a problem for an opponent, one should find a way to bundle useful and harmful functions. In the case of the stinking St.Mark's body, the useful function, from the Alexandrian official's point of view, was the highly detectable odour of the body. To neutralize this useful function, the two Venetian merchants bundled it with an extremely harmful (for the official's) function - untouchable pig carcasses. As the result, the officials became incapable of detecting St Mark's body, despite its highly conspicious odour.