Showing posts with label constraints. Show all posts
Showing posts with label constraints. Show all posts

Friday, July 10, 2015

Principles of Invention and Innovation (BUS 74), Session 2, Quiz 2.

During Session 2, several teams came up with a typical real estate trade-off: the nicer the neighborhood, the pricier it is going to be to buy or rent there.

Assignment 1. Using divergent thinking, list as many constraints behind the trade-off as you can (no criticism; both pragmatic and wild ideas are welcome). Optional: to help expand the scope of your search, apply either the Three Magicians or the STM operator (Scalable Innovation, Part II, Chapters 6, 9-10).



Assignment 2. In his book "Triumph of the City", Edward Glaeser, professor of economics at Harvard University, writes,
One of the bedrock principles of economics is that free lunches are rare and markets require trade-offs. [...] suburbanites can get a bigger lot at the cost of a longer commute. In comparing metropolitan areas, there is a three-way trade-off among wages, prices, and quality of life.
Question: Can you come up with an example of an existing or future solution that breaks at least one of these trade-offs?

Wednesday, December 07, 2011

Lunch Talk. Paul Romer's radical idea: Charter cities.

Stanford economist Paul Romer talks about his idea of Charter Cities and rules for changing rules.


tags: lunchtalk, infrastructure, constraints, control

Monday, May 23, 2011

How to Invent: Reverse Brainstorming (part 4). Problem selection.

The second half of Reverse Brainstorming is Problem Selection.  By the end of the session, we have to select problems that are worth solving, i.e. the problems that are worth our investment of time, money, and effort. Everything else (like 95%) is noise.

Here's a couple of diagrams illustrating the outcome of the session:



As you can see, numbered problems from the list created during the first part are first assigned Value and Timing, then sorted accordingly. Since the Value dimension invokes many questions from participants, I'll have to explain it in a separate post.

On the other hand, Timing is understood intuitively. Nevertheless, it is still important to make sure everybody has the same frame of reference. For some people, like a startup product organization, short-term means six months; for others, like a nanotech research group, short-term means six years. To avoid confusion, both short-(ST) and long-term (LT) terms have to be defined before problem evaluation, e.g. ST = 1year, LT = 5years.

One important consideration to keep in mind, though. You, as the session moderator, have to have a more sophisticated understanding of timing because when it comes to invention most simple intuitive notions, even the familiar ones like timing, tend to be wrong.

Let me explain. Time measured in calendar years reflects periods of rotation of the Earth around the Sun: 1 year - one rotation, 5 years - five rotations. Unless your group is dealing with agricultural products or services, which depend on Sun patterns, the Earth's rotation has almost no connection with invention and innovation. I say almost, because we do have major purchasing seasons, e.g. Christmas, Chinese New Year, Back to School, etc. Nevertheless, real timing has nothing to do with the rotation of the Earth. Rather, orthogonal to our everyday thinking, innovation timing has to do with technology or business constraints. That is, short-term means we are working inside a set of constraints, while long-term means we've managed to break through at least some of them.

If you have time during the session, it might be a good idea to convey to the group the concept of timing as constraint-related, rather than calendar-related. Often, it gets people thinking outside of the box their intuitive mindset and leads to a better understanding of Value and problems that prevent us from getting to it.

tags: reverse brainstorming,  reverse brainstorm, book, course, stanford, constraints, time, high value.

Previous posts on Reverse Brainstorming Howto:
1. How to Invent: Reverse Brainstorming.
2. It may look like this.
3. Concept Diagram: Reverse vs Traditional Brainstorming

Thursday, April 09, 2009

Taboo trade-offs

I am reading a paper by A. Peter McGraw and Philip E. Tetlock about "taboo trade-offs", i.e. trade-offs that, according to the authors' definition, violate deeply held intuitions about relationships and sacred values. Examples would be buying and selling votes in political elections, buying and selling sex with one's girlfriend, etc.
The key insight from the article is that market-pricing(MP) approach that underlies modern monetary transactions is bound to trigger emotional resistance when used in a variety of social contexts.
The lesson for inventor and/or innovator is to appreciate social implications of the changes he/she proposes, and ensure that his/her business model either does not carry inherent contradictions, or, even better, helps promote a healthy combination of social and economic values.
For example, LinkedIn social network works well with a for-profit job ads market. The company makes money by facilitating access to employment, which benefits both, potential employees and employers. On the other hand, Facebook's attempts to monetize personal product/service prefrences of one's friends by selling targeted ads is often perceived negatively by the community, and is treated more like a nuisance, rather than a benefit.
As A.P.McGraw and P.E.Tetlock note, "It is socially awkward to do business in a profit-maximizing fashion across [social] relational boundaries."

Remarkably, the modern US health care system probably encourages growth of medical costs because it breaks a direct financial link between doctors and patients. Today, most of the payments are handled by hospitals and insurance companies that had been created specifically for profit-maximizing purposes. Huge government bureaucracies like Medicare and Medicaid are not perceived as a next-door neighbor either.

Also, a good quote to underline the difference between mundane (homo economicus) and inventive approach to trade-offs, "The capacity to make trade-offs efficiently is a defining attribute of homo economicus."



References: 
McGraw, A. P., P. E. Tetlock. 2005. Taboo trade-offs, relational framing and the acceptability of exchanges. J. Consumer Psych. 15 2–15.
Kristina Shampanier, et all. 2007. Zero as a Special Price: The True Value of Free Products. Marketing Science. Vol. 26, No. 6, November–December 2007, pp. 742–757.